Dear Maybelline,
I just saw a commercial for Baby Lips.
I do not like your product's name.
I'm sure that the product itself is good. The name and the gender-specific marketing, however, sent my thoughts spinning down a familiar road.
Baby Lips. Marketed towards women and girls.
Let's start with the gender essentialism of marketing a body-neutral product towards only half of the population. Only women age? Only women get dehydrated?
Oh, I get it! Only women need to worry about aging! Only women need to worry about staying moist! Men, you see, get to be "ruggedly" handsome while women need to slather moisturizers and anti-aging products all over their faces (and necks and hands and so on) lest anyone consider them not youthfully dewy.
A woman's lips must be baby soft. As if they haven't changed since infancy. As if they haven't aged. As if they haven't gone through the natural maturation process. A woman should look young and innocent and immature as long as possible.
Are you literally infantilizing women?
There's pressure on women to conform to a lot of ideals and stereotypes, some of them contradictory. One of them is that women must be youthful and vulnerable and innocent, requiring men to protect them from the harshness of life. You know how women are, with their wide, innocent eyes and their girlish figures and their bell-like peals of happy laughter ringing with the sweet joy of children at play.
The narratives around women and girls and babies, the narratives warning women that aging is bad for them and maturity is suspect, the narratives that men are interesting and important and attractive over a wide number of decades but women need to cling to youth at all costs, are legion. You know them very well. You're playing into them and promoting them and profiting off of them.
The next time I need lip balm, I'll skip the Maybelline displays and buy something that doesn't tell women to be ashamed to be affected by the passing of time.
I hope that your next product comes with less gender essentialism and fewer hateful messages.
With love,
Frank Lee
Friday, August 24, 2012
Dear Me
Dear Me,
I want you to remember to be a good ally.
I want you to remember that communication is a complex thing and sometimes you'll express yourself poorly. Sometimes you'll use the wrong words. Sometimes you'll imply something you never intended to express. That's unfortunate, but it happens. Acknowledge it and strive to do better next time.
You want to be a good, progressive, inclusive feminist. Sometimes you're going to mess up. You're going to say something gross. You're going to bump into your own unexamined privilege. You're going to say things that you'll cringe over a couple of years from now. That's unfortunate, but it happens. Acknowledge it. Work on it. Dig that chunk of patriarchal programming out of your brain and examine it from all sides. Poke at what's left and see what else shakes loose.
You're going to piss people off. You're going to disgust them and alienate them. You're going to hurt them. That's awful. Remember that it's not about you, it's about them. It's about trying to improve so that you don't do it again.
Sometimes people will take exception to something you've said or written, and you'll think that they're wrong. You'll think that they're willfully misunderstanding you. Maybe they are. Maybe they're right, and you're really messing up. Take a deep breath. Talk it over. Think it over. Stop thinking about it from your perspective and think about it from theirs.
You know those people you can't stand who say disgusting, privileged things and sound like complete jackasses and act completely self-righteous about it? You know those people you can't stand who refuse to examine their mistakes and refuse to acknowledge their problems and deflect all blame and imply that there's something wrong with anyone who takes exception to their oh-so-obviously well-meaning words? Don't be those people.
It takes a lot of work to be a decent person. It takes a lot of empathy. But look at the alternative.
With love,
Frank Lee
I want you to remember to be a good ally.
I want you to remember that communication is a complex thing and sometimes you'll express yourself poorly. Sometimes you'll use the wrong words. Sometimes you'll imply something you never intended to express. That's unfortunate, but it happens. Acknowledge it and strive to do better next time.
You want to be a good, progressive, inclusive feminist. Sometimes you're going to mess up. You're going to say something gross. You're going to bump into your own unexamined privilege. You're going to say things that you'll cringe over a couple of years from now. That's unfortunate, but it happens. Acknowledge it. Work on it. Dig that chunk of patriarchal programming out of your brain and examine it from all sides. Poke at what's left and see what else shakes loose.
You're going to piss people off. You're going to disgust them and alienate them. You're going to hurt them. That's awful. Remember that it's not about you, it's about them. It's about trying to improve so that you don't do it again.
Sometimes people will take exception to something you've said or written, and you'll think that they're wrong. You'll think that they're willfully misunderstanding you. Maybe they are. Maybe they're right, and you're really messing up. Take a deep breath. Talk it over. Think it over. Stop thinking about it from your perspective and think about it from theirs.
You know those people you can't stand who say disgusting, privileged things and sound like complete jackasses and act completely self-righteous about it? You know those people you can't stand who refuse to examine their mistakes and refuse to acknowledge their problems and deflect all blame and imply that there's something wrong with anyone who takes exception to their oh-so-obviously well-meaning words? Don't be those people.
It takes a lot of work to be a decent person. It takes a lot of empathy. But look at the alternative.
With love,
Frank Lee
Dear Fat Hater
Dear Fat Hater,
You claim to be worried about my health.
Let's talk about health insurance and the terrible healthcare industry we have in this country.
Let's talk about how fat-phobic doctors abuse and neglect fat patients, misdiagnosing and misinforming us.
You claim to be concerned with my appearance.
Let's talk about how fat people are charged more for our clothes while designers style clothing to hide us, not flatter us.
Let's talk about our lookist society and how the shape of my body affects things like the jobs I can get, how much I'll be paid, and how well I'll be treated.
You claim to fear for my social life.
Let's talk about how years of fat-phobic messaging, including comments from you and people like you, affects my interactions.
Let's talk about rape culture.
You're chock full of warnings and concern, but you're aiming them in the wrong directions. If you genuinely want to help, start with the patriarchy.
But that would be hard work, and you're not really that worried about me, anyway. What you're worried about is yourself. You're concerned that there are fat people around you and that you might have to look at them. You're concerned that there are fat people around you and that you might be associated with them.
Your shitty attitude and the hatred inside you are far uglier than any roll of fat.
With love,
Frank Lee
You claim to be worried about my health.
Let's talk about health insurance and the terrible healthcare industry we have in this country.
Let's talk about how fat-phobic doctors abuse and neglect fat patients, misdiagnosing and misinforming us.
You claim to be concerned with my appearance.
Let's talk about how fat people are charged more for our clothes while designers style clothing to hide us, not flatter us.
Let's talk about our lookist society and how the shape of my body affects things like the jobs I can get, how much I'll be paid, and how well I'll be treated.
You claim to fear for my social life.
Let's talk about how years of fat-phobic messaging, including comments from you and people like you, affects my interactions.
Let's talk about rape culture.
You're chock full of warnings and concern, but you're aiming them in the wrong directions. If you genuinely want to help, start with the patriarchy.
But that would be hard work, and you're not really that worried about me, anyway. What you're worried about is yourself. You're concerned that there are fat people around you and that you might have to look at them. You're concerned that there are fat people around you and that you might be associated with them.
Your shitty attitude and the hatred inside you are far uglier than any roll of fat.
With love,
Frank Lee
Tuesday, August 21, 2012
Dear Todd Akin
Discussion of rape and rape culture to follow.
You don't seem to understand what's actually going on. I've been focusing on other angles of this issue because I assumed that everyone else was covering it aptly, but apparently you haven't been paying attention.
Let's take it back to what you actually said.
Although, if you understand that "legitimate" was wrong, and you understand why it was wrong, it seems contradictory for you to defend yourself with, "I haven’t done anything morally or ethically wrong." Separating out rape into "legitimate rape" and "forcible rape" and "rape-rape" and so on seems morally wrong to me. It's disgusting and morally repugnant to act as if "violent stranger rape" is real rape, and the other kinds are less-than-rape, kinda-sorta rape, not really rape. Calling certain kinds of rape "legitimate" as if the rest are not is doing something morally wrong.
But you say that you didn't mean to say "legitimate." Let's take you at your word. Here's what you apparently meant to say:
I don't know who those doctors were, but they're poorly educated and spreading dangerous misinformation. Pregnancy from rape is not "really rare." According to the American Journal of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, an estimated “32,101 pregnancies result from rape each year.” Consider that: 32,101. Each year. In one country. More significant than "really rare," I'd say.
Then we get to: "If it's rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down."
If it's rape? If? If it's really rape. Because, you know, it might not be. It could be one of those "she cried rape" situations. One of those cases of morning-after regrets. She was asking for it, you know.
Women do not have unique powers of mind control. Women do not have "ways" to circumvent their bodies natural processes. A lot of physical functions are autonomic. Women can't make their hearts stop pumping or make their stomachs stop digesting, so why would you think that they'd be able to stop their reproductive organs from working?
This, of course, is where the patriarchy steps in to remind us that women's reproductive systems are very mysterious and sort of magical and can't ever really be understood by men. Women are, of course, basically incomprehensible. The answer to my last question was "misogyny."
It is true that in certain situations, some women's bodies may respond to great stress by miscarrying. That is true of some women in some situations. Just as "salad and jogging" doesn't equate to "lose 5 pounds a week" like some magical formula, "rape and stress" doesn't equate to "miscarriage" or "infertility." Everyone's body is different. Everyone's body reacts differently. All women are not the same. A lot of women have hearty bodies and smoothly functioning organs which will go on merrily about their business no matter how much distress the woman has been through. You can be in a car accident and continue to digest. You can be shot and still continue to breathe. You can be raped and still become pregnant.
In that one sentence, you basically said, "I'm incredibly ill-informed, I'm either lying or I have no ability to discern reputable sources from uneducated fools, I don't understand women, I know little to nothing about women's experiences, I support and promote rape culture, I think that women lie, and I need to educate myself immediately on human biology." In other words, "I'm a mendacious, incompetent asshole and I hate women."
If that's not what you meant, you have some work to do.
But you didn't stop there! The fun just kept flowing:
When someone is pregnant, "there should be some punishment." That's what you said. The magical rape-infertility process failed, the way magical processes sometimes do, and now the rape victim is pregnant. "There should be some punishment," is your response.
Are you advocating for jail time for rape, and extra jail time for rape plus impregnation? Is this a new bill you're working on? Maybe jail time plus expenses for mental health and abortion costs and, oh, no, that can't be it. You think that abortion should be illegal. Period. Across the board. For everyone, at all times.
Now it's time for you to hop on over and read what I wrote to your pal Mike Huckabee about this. I'll wait.
Back? Okay!
Overall, in a few sentences, you said that sometimes rape isn't really rape. You lied about human biology in a way that turns at least 32,101 Americans a year into liars who weren't really raped. You declared that a legal and safe medical procedure should be made illegal because, uh, why? You turned a pregnancy into a living, independent, human child to make abortion look bad (and to make people who have abortions look bad). You want to force rape victims to endure nine months of pregnancy plus labor to bear a rapist's child at a time when they most need to be in control of their own bodies.
You have a lot of learning to do. Starting with what "morally or ethically wrong" means.
With love,
Frank Lee
“...I said one word and one sentence on one day, and everything changed,” Akin told Huckabee, an early supporter. “I haven’t done anything morally or ethically wrong. It does seem like a little bit of an overreaction.”Dear Todd Akin,
-Todd Akin
You don't seem to understand what's actually going on. I've been focusing on other angles of this issue because I assumed that everyone else was covering it aptly, but apparently you haven't been paying attention.
Let's take it back to what you actually said.
"First of all, from what I understand from doctors [pregnancy from rape] is really rare," Akin told KTVI-TV in an interview posted Sunday. "If it's a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down."According to you, the "one word" you "misspoke" was "legitimate." I'm glad that you understand how wrong it was to say that. It was an incredibly hateful, policing thing to say, the sort of verbiage I'd expect from a promoter of rape culture, and it's good that you realize it was wrong.
Akin said that even in the worst-case scenario — when the supposed natural protections against unwanted pregnancy fail — abortion should still not be a legal option for the rape victim.
"Let's assume that maybe that didn't work, or something," Akin said. "I think there should be some punishment, but the punishment ought to be on the rapist and not attacking the child."
Although, if you understand that "legitimate" was wrong, and you understand why it was wrong, it seems contradictory for you to defend yourself with, "I haven’t done anything morally or ethically wrong." Separating out rape into "legitimate rape" and "forcible rape" and "rape-rape" and so on seems morally wrong to me. It's disgusting and morally repugnant to act as if "violent stranger rape" is real rape, and the other kinds are less-than-rape, kinda-sorta rape, not really rape. Calling certain kinds of rape "legitimate" as if the rest are not is doing something morally wrong.
But you say that you didn't mean to say "legitimate." Let's take you at your word. Here's what you apparently meant to say:
"First of all, from what I understand from doctors [pregnancy from rape] is really rare," Akin told KTVI-TV in an interview posted Sunday. "If it's rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down."Well, that's terrible.
Akin said that even in the worst-case scenario — when the supposed natural protections against unwanted pregnancy fail — abortion should still not be a legal option for the rape victim.
"Let's assume that maybe that didn't work, or something," Akin said. "I think there should be some punishment, but the punishment ought to be on the rapist and not attacking the child."
I don't know who those doctors were, but they're poorly educated and spreading dangerous misinformation. Pregnancy from rape is not "really rare." According to the American Journal of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, an estimated “32,101 pregnancies result from rape each year.” Consider that: 32,101. Each year. In one country. More significant than "really rare," I'd say.
Then we get to: "If it's rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down."
If it's rape? If? If it's really rape. Because, you know, it might not be. It could be one of those "she cried rape" situations. One of those cases of morning-after regrets. She was asking for it, you know.
Women do not have unique powers of mind control. Women do not have "ways" to circumvent their bodies natural processes. A lot of physical functions are autonomic. Women can't make their hearts stop pumping or make their stomachs stop digesting, so why would you think that they'd be able to stop their reproductive organs from working?
This, of course, is where the patriarchy steps in to remind us that women's reproductive systems are very mysterious and sort of magical and can't ever really be understood by men. Women are, of course, basically incomprehensible. The answer to my last question was "misogyny."
It is true that in certain situations, some women's bodies may respond to great stress by miscarrying. That is true of some women in some situations. Just as "salad and jogging" doesn't equate to "lose 5 pounds a week" like some magical formula, "rape and stress" doesn't equate to "miscarriage" or "infertility." Everyone's body is different. Everyone's body reacts differently. All women are not the same. A lot of women have hearty bodies and smoothly functioning organs which will go on merrily about their business no matter how much distress the woman has been through. You can be in a car accident and continue to digest. You can be shot and still continue to breathe. You can be raped and still become pregnant.
In that one sentence, you basically said, "I'm incredibly ill-informed, I'm either lying or I have no ability to discern reputable sources from uneducated fools, I don't understand women, I know little to nothing about women's experiences, I support and promote rape culture, I think that women lie, and I need to educate myself immediately on human biology." In other words, "I'm a mendacious, incompetent asshole and I hate women."
If that's not what you meant, you have some work to do.
But you didn't stop there! The fun just kept flowing:
...abortion should still not be a legal option for the rape victim.As I said, you don't seem to understand human biology very well. To clarify, there is no child. "Attacking a child" brings to mind images of someone assaulting a five-year-old. When someone aborts a pregnancy, that's something that happens (pay attention here) while she's pregnant.
"Let's assume that maybe that didn't work, or something," Akin said. "I think there should be some punishment, but the punishment ought to be on the rapist and not attacking the child."
abort a pregnancy =/= attack a childWith the basics of the life cycle out of the way, let's look at the rest of this nonsense.
When someone is pregnant, "there should be some punishment." That's what you said. The magical rape-infertility process failed, the way magical processes sometimes do, and now the rape victim is pregnant. "There should be some punishment," is your response.
Are you advocating for jail time for rape, and extra jail time for rape plus impregnation? Is this a new bill you're working on? Maybe jail time plus expenses for mental health and abortion costs and, oh, no, that can't be it. You think that abortion should be illegal. Period. Across the board. For everyone, at all times.
Now it's time for you to hop on over and read what I wrote to your pal Mike Huckabee about this. I'll wait.
Back? Okay!
Overall, in a few sentences, you said that sometimes rape isn't really rape. You lied about human biology in a way that turns at least 32,101 Americans a year into liars who weren't really raped. You declared that a legal and safe medical procedure should be made illegal because, uh, why? You turned a pregnancy into a living, independent, human child to make abortion look bad (and to make people who have abortions look bad). You want to force rape victims to endure nine months of pregnancy plus labor to bear a rapist's child at a time when they most need to be in control of their own bodies.
You have a lot of learning to do. Starting with what "morally or ethically wrong" means.
With love,
Frank Lee
Dear Steve King
Discussion of rape and rape culture to follow.
Dear Steve King,
As a Congressman, you must do a lot of talking in front of microphones and reporters. It's understandable that you might word your thoughts awkwardly from time to time.
I don't think that's what's happening here.
Here's what a reporter asked you:
All of that conveys a very clear idea that you doubt the situation exists. You know nothing of it and if it were real, someone would have told you by now. You're open to it, after all!
Which is an odd stance to take, considering what you said only weeks earlier (emphasis mine):
You're comfortable with rape as your go-to point illustrator, but you're completely unfamiliar with it in real life.
The victimization of girls "happens in America more times than you and I like to think" but if it happens you'd like to hear about it.
Try to take this in: rape is not just a convenient hypothetical. The victimization of girls isn't just a rhetorical device. This is a reality. You know that it's a reality. You don't get to pretend that it doesn't happen when it suddenly becomes politically unpleasant.
While we're here, let's talk about the rest of that blather. "I think it’s immoral for us to compel conscientious objecting taxpayers to fund abortion through the federal government, or any other government for that matter." Isn't it also immoral for to compel us to fund war? Are you campaigning against that?
But that's not a fair comparison, is it? War is a violent atrocity. Abortion is a legal medical procedure. In war, people are killed in great numbers. In abortion, pregnancy is ended. Oh, but war is necessary, you'd argue! Abortion is necessary, too, to protect the health, livelihood, quantity and quality of life of millions of Americans.
We pay taxes for the greater good. It's part of living in a thriving society. In a functioning society, people need access to medical services, health care, and reproductive rights, even if you personally don't agree with their choices. I don't like war, so I don't start wars and I haven't signed up for the military. I urge you not to get an abortion.
With love,
Frank Lee
P.S. Your apparent stance on animal cruelty makes me want to go hug a dog.
Dear Steve King,
As a Congressman, you must do a lot of talking in front of microphones and reporters. It's understandable that you might word your thoughts awkwardly from time to time.
I don't think that's what's happening here.
Here's what a reporter asked you:
You support the No Taxpayer Funding for Abortion Act that would provide federal funding for abortions to a person that has been forcefully raped. But what if someone isn’t forcibly raped and for example, a 12-year-old who gets pregnant? Should she have to bring this baby to term?Here's your direct reply:
Well I just haven’t heard of that being a circumstance that’s been brought to me in any personal way and I’d be open to hearing discussion about that subject matter. Generally speaking it’s this: that there millions of abortions in this country every year. Millions of them are paid for at least in part by taxpayers. I think it’s immoral for us to compel conscientious objecting taxpayers to fund abortion through the federal government, or any other government for that matter. So that’s my stand. And if there are exceptions there, then bring me those exceptions let’s talk about it. In the meantime it’s wrong for us to compel pro-life people to pay taxes to fund abortion.On the subject of a 12-year-old being impregnated by her rapist, the first words out of your mouth are, "Well, I just haven't heard of that being a circumstance," as if it's imaginary, a flight of fancy. You follow that up with, "that's been brought to me in any personal way," as if you'd need the 12-year-old in question to approach you about it personally. Then you get to, "if there are exceptions here, then bring me those exceptions." "Let's talk about it," you say. "In the meantime..."
All of that conveys a very clear idea that you doubt the situation exists. You know nothing of it and if it were real, someone would have told you by now. You're open to it, after all!
Which is an odd stance to take, considering what you said only weeks earlier (emphasis mine):
What I've said is that we need to respect humans more than we do animals. Whenever we start elevating animals up to, to above that of humans, we've crossed a moral line. For example, if there's a sexual predator out there who has impregnated a young girl, say a 13 year old girl, and it happens in America more times than you and I like to think, that sexual predator can pick that girl off the playground at the middle school and haul her across the state line and force her to get an abortion to eradicate the evidence of his crime, and bring her back and drop her off at the swing set, and that's not against the law in the United States of America. I have told Wayne Pacelle and the people who believe we should focus all of our efforts on the, on anything they can bring that limits activity around animals, that we need to respect and revere human life first, animal life second.The rape and impregnation of teenaged girls makes a great hypothetical when you need a handy comparison to dog fighting, but it's an anomaly, a flight of fancy that you've certainly never encountered before, when it's the actual topic at hand.
You're comfortable with rape as your go-to point illustrator, but you're completely unfamiliar with it in real life.
The victimization of girls "happens in America more times than you and I like to think" but if it happens you'd like to hear about it.
Try to take this in: rape is not just a convenient hypothetical. The victimization of girls isn't just a rhetorical device. This is a reality. You know that it's a reality. You don't get to pretend that it doesn't happen when it suddenly becomes politically unpleasant.
While we're here, let's talk about the rest of that blather. "I think it’s immoral for us to compel conscientious objecting taxpayers to fund abortion through the federal government, or any other government for that matter." Isn't it also immoral for to compel us to fund war? Are you campaigning against that?
But that's not a fair comparison, is it? War is a violent atrocity. Abortion is a legal medical procedure. In war, people are killed in great numbers. In abortion, pregnancy is ended. Oh, but war is necessary, you'd argue! Abortion is necessary, too, to protect the health, livelihood, quantity and quality of life of millions of Americans.
We pay taxes for the greater good. It's part of living in a thriving society. In a functioning society, people need access to medical services, health care, and reproductive rights, even if you personally don't agree with their choices. I don't like war, so I don't start wars and I haven't signed up for the military. I urge you not to get an abortion.
With love,
Frank Lee
P.S. Your apparent stance on animal cruelty makes me want to go hug a dog.
Dear Mike Huckabee
Discussion of rape and rape culture ahead.
Before we go any farther, stop saying "forcible rape." Just say "rape." The term "forcible rape" makes it seem as if there's "forcible rape," which is the bad, violent kind, and then there's other rape, you know, not rape-rape, just sort-of-rape, it wasn't really forcible or anything, she just wasn't that into it, you know how women are.
With that out of the way, let's examine the rest of that dreck.
Right, so basically you're saying that "some people make the best of a bad situation." Or, "the sperm of rapists isn't automatically contaminated with evil." Or something. What's your point here? Yes, some people grow up to "do extraordinary things." That's terrific! I agree!
Here's the thing about that "life has come" part. "Life has come" is a really vague way to gloss over the fact that someone had to endure nine months of pregnancy followed by labor (and we all know what a sweet little tea party that always is). And then someone (most often the person who just did the whole pregnancy-and-labor thing) has to rear the child. For a long time.
What you said, that sometimes people who have been raped become pregnant and bear children, and sometimes those children grow up to become professional Christians, is a fact. It is not an argument. (Although you were speaking with Todd Akin at the time, so, "Yes, you fool, sometimes people do get pregnant from being raped" is, unfortunately, not taken for granted.)
It is true that people conceived through rape may contribute positively to the world. It's not as if the seed of rapists is sown in Lucifer's garden or anything. It's not as if "I must rape" is encoded into the chromosomes somewhere, just waiting for the next generation. No one's suggesting that we're suffering an epidemic of rape babies growing up to be a drain on society.
But let's look at why someone who's been raped may not want to continue a pregnancy.
1.) Well, you were just raped, so you're probably going through a lot right now, so dealing with that and taking care of yourself comes first.
2.) The pregnancy may be a constant reminder of the assault you've just suffered.
3.) Being raped involves a loss of control, an inability to stop someone else from using your body. A pregnancy can be uncomfortably similar at a time when you want to reestablish control.
4.) As you probably weren't planning to be raped and become pregnant, you probably weren't preparing your life for child-rearing. You may not be ready for pregnancy or parenthood, financially or physically or otherwise.
5.) You may be married or have a significant other who is unwilling to help you to rear your rapist's child.
6.) People are going to ask who the father is.
7.) The child is going to ask who the father is.
8.) What if the father wants visitation rights? What if he pops up five years down the road and tries to involve himself in your child's life? Statistically speaking, you were probably raped by someone you know. You can only guess how he'll react if he realizes that the child is his. Even if he doesn't get involved initially, he has the rest of the child's life to change his mind.
9.) Along with the "raped by someone you know" part comes the fact that you may know the rapist's significant other, the rapist's children, etc. You may be a member of the rapist's family.
10.) If you're one of the few who ends up seeing a rapist on trial, I can only imagine how the defense will twist "but she's carrying his baby!" into an argument that it wasn't really rape.
There's a lot more, but you get the gist of it. While you may think of pregnancy as the potential for another wonderful Christian in the world, the actual rape victim has a much more complex understanding of the situation. You can pat yourself on the back for acknowledging how indefensible "forcible" rape is, but maybe if you had more feminists who fight the rape culture and work for reproductive rights on your show, and fewer people like Todd Akin, you'd be more respectful of what real survivors go through.
With love,
Frank Lee
"Ethel Waters, for example, was the result of a forcible rape," Huckabee said of the late American gospel singer. One-time presidential candidate Huckabee added: "I used to work for James Robison back in the 1970s, he leads a large Christian organization. He, himself, was the result of a forcible rape. And so I know it happens, and yet even from those horrible, horrible tragedies of rape, which are inexcusable and indefensible, life has come and sometimes, you know, those people are able to do extraordinary things."Dear Mike Huckabee,
-Mike Huckabee
Before we go any farther, stop saying "forcible rape." Just say "rape." The term "forcible rape" makes it seem as if there's "forcible rape," which is the bad, violent kind, and then there's other rape, you know, not rape-rape, just sort-of-rape, it wasn't really forcible or anything, she just wasn't that into it, you know how women are.
With that out of the way, let's examine the rest of that dreck.
Right, so basically you're saying that "some people make the best of a bad situation." Or, "the sperm of rapists isn't automatically contaminated with evil." Or something. What's your point here? Yes, some people grow up to "do extraordinary things." That's terrific! I agree!
Here's the thing about that "life has come" part. "Life has come" is a really vague way to gloss over the fact that someone had to endure nine months of pregnancy followed by labor (and we all know what a sweet little tea party that always is). And then someone (most often the person who just did the whole pregnancy-and-labor thing) has to rear the child. For a long time.
What you said, that sometimes people who have been raped become pregnant and bear children, and sometimes those children grow up to become professional Christians, is a fact. It is not an argument. (Although you were speaking with Todd Akin at the time, so, "Yes, you fool, sometimes people do get pregnant from being raped" is, unfortunately, not taken for granted.)
It is true that people conceived through rape may contribute positively to the world. It's not as if the seed of rapists is sown in Lucifer's garden or anything. It's not as if "I must rape" is encoded into the chromosomes somewhere, just waiting for the next generation. No one's suggesting that we're suffering an epidemic of rape babies growing up to be a drain on society.
But let's look at why someone who's been raped may not want to continue a pregnancy.
1.) Well, you were just raped, so you're probably going through a lot right now, so dealing with that and taking care of yourself comes first.
2.) The pregnancy may be a constant reminder of the assault you've just suffered.
3.) Being raped involves a loss of control, an inability to stop someone else from using your body. A pregnancy can be uncomfortably similar at a time when you want to reestablish control.
4.) As you probably weren't planning to be raped and become pregnant, you probably weren't preparing your life for child-rearing. You may not be ready for pregnancy or parenthood, financially or physically or otherwise.
5.) You may be married or have a significant other who is unwilling to help you to rear your rapist's child.
6.) People are going to ask who the father is.
7.) The child is going to ask who the father is.
8.) What if the father wants visitation rights? What if he pops up five years down the road and tries to involve himself in your child's life? Statistically speaking, you were probably raped by someone you know. You can only guess how he'll react if he realizes that the child is his. Even if he doesn't get involved initially, he has the rest of the child's life to change his mind.
9.) Along with the "raped by someone you know" part comes the fact that you may know the rapist's significant other, the rapist's children, etc. You may be a member of the rapist's family.
10.) If you're one of the few who ends up seeing a rapist on trial, I can only imagine how the defense will twist "but she's carrying his baby!" into an argument that it wasn't really rape.
There's a lot more, but you get the gist of it. While you may think of pregnancy as the potential for another wonderful Christian in the world, the actual rape victim has a much more complex understanding of the situation. You can pat yourself on the back for acknowledging how indefensible "forcible" rape is, but maybe if you had more feminists who fight the rape culture and work for reproductive rights on your show, and fewer people like Todd Akin, you'd be more respectful of what real survivors go through.
With love,
Frank Lee
Dear Bic
Dear Bic,
I see that you've a "ball pen essentially for women!"
Essentially for women, you say. Essentially?
I suppose that it depends how you define "women." If you're going with "uterus-owners," maybe this pen doubles as a tampon? Is it a vaginal contraceptive device?
Maybe you're thinking of women as "those people who do feminine, girly things." Does the pen have ink at one end and mascara at the other? Lipstick! Is there lipstick involved?
Well, let's look at your pen's key benefits:
Maybe it's the modern design! You know how women are about design! That's like fashion, right?
I'm really not sure what it is about this pen that makes it a must-have for women while being completely irrelevant to everyone else in the world. Is the ink pink? The ink has to be pink, right?
Oh. The ink is either black or blue.
Those are awfully manly colors, don't you think?
I don't think that I'll be buying any more pens from you until you've gotten your act together. I'm looking at the pens on my desk, and they're not Bic. Do you know what their key benefits are? They're from companies who aren't promoting and profiting from gender essentialism!
Let me know if you ever do get that pen-tampon-vaginal contraceptive device thing worked out, though.
With love,
Frank Lee
I see that you've a "ball pen essentially for women!"
Essentially for women, you say. Essentially?
1 : of, relating to, or constituting essence : inherentIs this pen made with the essence of women? What have you put in that ink?
2Ah, your pen is indispensable to women! But not to anyone else? Only to women? Why would only women find this pen essential?
a : of the utmost importance : basic, indispensable, necessary <an essential requirement for admission to college>
I suppose that it depends how you define "women." If you're going with "uterus-owners," maybe this pen doubles as a tampon? Is it a vaginal contraceptive device?
Maybe you're thinking of women as "those people who do feminine, girly things." Does the pen have ink at one end and mascara at the other? Lipstick! Is there lipstick involved?
Well, let's look at your pen's key benefits:
Retractable ballpoint penUm. Those are sort of generic pen facts. What about this pen is specific to women? Is it the "fun comfort grip?" Maybe other pens are less fun, and fun pens are for women only? Or only women demand to be comfortable! So pampered!
Medium point: 1.00mm
Fun comfort grip
Modern design
Maybe it's the modern design! You know how women are about design! That's like fashion, right?
I'm really not sure what it is about this pen that makes it a must-have for women while being completely irrelevant to everyone else in the world. Is the ink pink? The ink has to be pink, right?
Oh. The ink is either black or blue.
Those are awfully manly colors, don't you think?
I don't think that I'll be buying any more pens from you until you've gotten your act together. I'm looking at the pens on my desk, and they're not Bic. Do you know what their key benefits are? They're from companies who aren't promoting and profiting from gender essentialism!
Let me know if you ever do get that pen-tampon-vaginal contraceptive device thing worked out, though.
With love,
Frank Lee
Dear YouTubers
Discussion of rape culture ahead.
Dear YouTubers,
I spend a lot of time on YouTube, and I've noticed that people have this habit of making comments about "raping" the replay button.
It's not funny, it's gross, but I bicker with myself over how to respond. Is an explanation of why not to use rape as a metaphor too long for a YouTube comment? Should I just step in with a mild, "hey, not cool?"
While I was on YouTube yesterday, I found someone named AfizaFarhana setting a great example.
It's a simple thing, but I found it encouraging. It's nice to know that other people are stepping up, and it's nice to see that she got so much support (and no push back, at least that I saw).
When we point out that someone's speech is hateful or harmful, it's not our job to make it palatable. We don't have to be sweet or witty or graceful about it. The problem isn't our approach, it's whatever the other person said in the first place. But I'm not socially adept at all times (understatement of the year) and I'm not always in the mood for a fight. Sometimes I just want to make my point and get out. It's nice to pick up examples of how to word my comments for maximum effectiveness and minimum engagement.
What's your go-to wording when you speak up?
With love,
Frank Lee
Dear YouTubers,
I spend a lot of time on YouTube, and I've noticed that people have this habit of making comments about "raping" the replay button.
It's not funny, it's gross, but I bicker with myself over how to respond. Is an explanation of why not to use rape as a metaphor too long for a YouTube comment? Should I just step in with a mild, "hey, not cool?"
While I was on YouTube yesterday, I found someone named AfizaFarhana setting a great example.
‘Rape’ the replay button is not so healthy anyway...it's crime...just try ‘refreshing’ your relationship with this MV...XDThe last time I checked, she had 58 "likes."
It's a simple thing, but I found it encouraging. It's nice to know that other people are stepping up, and it's nice to see that she got so much support (and no push back, at least that I saw).
When we point out that someone's speech is hateful or harmful, it's not our job to make it palatable. We don't have to be sweet or witty or graceful about it. The problem isn't our approach, it's whatever the other person said in the first place. But I'm not socially adept at all times (understatement of the year) and I'm not always in the mood for a fight. Sometimes I just want to make my point and get out. It's nice to pick up examples of how to word my comments for maximum effectiveness and minimum engagement.
What's your go-to wording when you speak up?
With love,
Frank Lee
Friday, August 17, 2012
Dear President Obama
"It's kind of a weird superpower, but if I had something that I could immediately wish for, I would love to be able to speak any language," the president said.Dear President Obama,
"Now, that's a weird superpower—it might not come in handy to rescue folks from a burning building," he added. "But I've always wished that whatever country I went to, wherever I met somebody who spoke a different language, that I could right away speak their language."
Some of the qualities I wish for most in a president are also the qualities I appreciate in anyone. Empathy, for example. A desire for inclusiveness. An interest in other people and the variety of human existence.
Your preferred superpower is a beautiful wish that says a lot of terrific things about you. You want to understand people. You want to connect with them, and you want to do it on their terms.
What says more about wanting to understand someone than speaking their language? That's our go-to phrase for communication! That's how we illustrate that someone doesn't get us: we're not speaking the same language.
You and I have had our disagreements in the past, but you do have many of the qualities I wish every president had. This was a lovely, smart answer to a cliched question. Thank you.
With love,
Frank Lee
Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Dear Blizzard
Dear Blizzard,
Congratulations on your new toys! I hope that they sell well.
I realize that this is only the initial launch and that more sets and figures will be released in the future. Even so, you may have overlooked a few things.
Like women.
In the 13 sets and 19 characters available, there are no women.
You're also missing a few of the races. You got most of the important ones in, like the default races (human and orc), the shiny new races (worgen and goblin) and so on. No gnomes yet, of course. (You and I are long overdue for a talk about gnomes.)
Maybe I'm not being fair, but it's easy to draw a parallel. You got the default in, right? You got the important one: men. Women are, you know, the extra, the add-on, the one you'll get to later. You'll get around to adding them in eventually. What's important is that we have lots of men! Important men from lore! Men riding gryphons! Men standing around looking important!
You know this is a problem. You've heard from us for years about how you marginalize women. Oh, we hope for the best. We imagine that somewhere on your end, someone's trying to fix the problem. And then you launch a new project with 19 characters and no women, and we feel like fools for ever giving you the benefit of the doubt.
We want to be on your side. We want to enjoy your game and have fun with you. We're passionate, paying customers. We put up with a lot of shit from misogynistic gamer guys to stick with you, so we aren't that thrilled to get shit from you, too. And the more crap you pull, the more encouragement and permission the players have for their behavior, too. Again: you know this is a problem, and you continue to contribute to it.
Ideally, your 19 characters would be an even split, 10 women and 9 men or 10 men and 9 women. If you want to marginalize us, you could make it 15 men and 4 women. For a token 10%, you could have 2 women. Maybe one? Just one? Just one woman? No?
Was this a deliberate choice? Did you think that having the option to buy a woman on a gryphon instead of a man on a gryphon would upset your player base? Did you think that people shopping in Toys 'R' Us would see your products and get excited, and then notice a woman character among the men and be turned off enough not to try your game? Or did you put no thought into this at all? Did it never even occur to you to include women?
Congratulations on your new toys. I hope that they sell well. I won't be buying any of them.
With love,
Frank Lee
Congratulations on your new toys! I hope that they sell well.
I realize that this is only the initial launch and that more sets and figures will be released in the future. Even so, you may have overlooked a few things.
Like women.
In the 13 sets and 19 characters available, there are no women.
You're also missing a few of the races. You got most of the important ones in, like the default races (human and orc), the shiny new races (worgen and goblin) and so on. No gnomes yet, of course. (You and I are long overdue for a talk about gnomes.)
Maybe I'm not being fair, but it's easy to draw a parallel. You got the default in, right? You got the important one: men. Women are, you know, the extra, the add-on, the one you'll get to later. You'll get around to adding them in eventually. What's important is that we have lots of men! Important men from lore! Men riding gryphons! Men standing around looking important!
You know this is a problem. You've heard from us for years about how you marginalize women. Oh, we hope for the best. We imagine that somewhere on your end, someone's trying to fix the problem. And then you launch a new project with 19 characters and no women, and we feel like fools for ever giving you the benefit of the doubt.
We want to be on your side. We want to enjoy your game and have fun with you. We're passionate, paying customers. We put up with a lot of shit from misogynistic gamer guys to stick with you, so we aren't that thrilled to get shit from you, too. And the more crap you pull, the more encouragement and permission the players have for their behavior, too. Again: you know this is a problem, and you continue to contribute to it.
Ideally, your 19 characters would be an even split, 10 women and 9 men or 10 men and 9 women. If you want to marginalize us, you could make it 15 men and 4 women. For a token 10%, you could have 2 women. Maybe one? Just one? Just one woman? No?
Was this a deliberate choice? Did you think that having the option to buy a woman on a gryphon instead of a man on a gryphon would upset your player base? Did you think that people shopping in Toys 'R' Us would see your products and get excited, and then notice a woman character among the men and be turned off enough not to try your game? Or did you put no thought into this at all? Did it never even occur to you to include women?
Congratulations on your new toys. I hope that they sell well. I won't be buying any of them.
With love,
Frank Lee
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)